The Fascinating $1 Million 1909-S VDB Wheat Penny and 4 Other Unique Coin Treasures

Introduction

One of the most valuable coins in existence is the 1909-S V.D.B. Wheat Penny. The small copper piece, with the initials of its designer Victor David Brenner, has fascinated many collectors over the years. Only 484,000 were minted, so it is extremely rare and historically and numismatically important.

Coin collection rarely offers more interesting anecdotes from the history of the Americans than minting blunders or unexpected discoveries. It would sell for about a million dollars at auction in order to prove itself for many years to be precious.

In this guide, we examine the incredible story of that precious penny and four more rare coins that shaped America’s numismatics and explore their value, method of identification, and ever-present appeal to collectors from around the world.

The 1909-S V.D.B. Wheat Penny: A Collector’s Dream

This was the first coin in the Lincoln Cent series, but of much significance in American coin collecting history. The San Francisco minted only 484,000 coins, which makes this a very rare penny, as the Philadelphia Mint produced 27.9 million pieces for that particular year.

The Significance of the Designer’s Initials

This makes the coin unique, for on the reverse side, it bears the designer’s initials, “V.D.B.” -Victor David Brenner-under two stalks of wheat. The public was shocked at the discovery of his initials and considered them obtrusive and self-indulgent. So in days following its release, the initials were removed.

An Unintentional Rarity

This inadvertently resulted in a rare coin. The San Francisco Mint had already produced its lot of pennies when the removal order was made, thus the 1909-S V.D.B. penny automatically became a collectible piece. The mintmark “S” is on the obverse while the reverse shows the famous wheat ears that were used for Lincoln cents until 1958.

Why Collectors Covet It

The limited mintage along with its historical importance, besides the controversy of the V.D.B. has built a tremendous demand for the coin from collectors all over the world-numismatists.

Value Assessment

It depends if it’s graded or in mint condition and if it has a certain color designation. The used piece with an average grade goes for about $ 950 and is not expensive.

Price according to grading is:

• MS60 (Mint State): $1,125 – $1,500
• MS63: $2,500-$4,000
• MS65: $15,000-$25,000
• MS67: $75,000-$345,375

The coins with the highest demand are considered Mint State Red (RD) – those retaining at least 95% of their original copper-red luster. Those flawless coins have brought fantastic money at major auction sales. In 2021, a 1909-S VDB penny graded MS67+ RD brought a record price, when it sold for $345,375 at an auction by Heritage Auctions.

Reportage has said that in private sales, a few MS68 RD coins sold as high as $4 million. Value of the coin keeps accelerating because collectors keep on reaching out for the best specimens to add in their collections.

Exploring Other Rare Finds in Coin Collecting

The world of rare coins is far more than simply the fabled 1909-S VDB Wheat Penny. Dedicated collectors frantically search for these obscure treasures, each having fascinating stories and unique characteristics all its own.

1. The 1943 Lincoln Cent on Bronze Planchet

Among numismatics, the most interesting error coin is one with the date 1943 on its Lincoln Cent. During World War II, the U.S. Mint, while trying to ration copper for the war effort, was forced to stop using the metal in pennies and instead used zinc-coated steel. What then occurred is that several copper planchets made in 1942 remained in the production stream, inadvertently allowing for the introduction of a small number of extremely rare bronze pieces.

Key Features:

• Struck on residual copper planchets rather than the regular 1943 steel
• Approximately 40 confirmed specimens exist at all mints
• Authenticated pieces sell for more than $100,000
• Rusty coloration of the copper planchets vs. the steel counterparts

Historical Significance:

The 1943 Bronze Lincoln Cent is one of those coins that, through a series of very odd events, connected America directly to its wartime history. The pennies stand as evidence of the effort of this nation to preserve its resources during World War II. Their striking was strictly an accident, which makes them a true numismatic anomaly.

Collector Appeal:

These coins happen to be rare for several reasons:

• They are mistakenly error coins
• Only very few exist
• Their historical production
• Their vastness of appearance in comparison with normal 1943 steel cents

Recent sales have seen these coins achieve astronomical prices. Well-preserved specimens sell for $250,000 to $500,000. The finest grades command prices that approach $1 million at specialty auctions. This is a market with more than a few forged examples.

2. The 1937-D 3-Legged Buffalo Nickel

The 1937-D 3-Legged Buffalo Nickel is one of the interesting error varieties in the American coin collecting world. The coin was minted when an employee of the Denver Mint accidentally buffed one of the dies too hard, knocking off a leg of the buffalo. So the buffalo is seen as balancing on three legs rather than four.

Why It’s Special

What is unique in this coin is the mistake created in the process of its minting. It’s a buffalo nickel with the missing leg that is pretty distinct compared to any other. This, indeed, is a classic human mistake sometimes made during the production of some works, bringing with it surprise and merit-worthy products.

Rarity and Value

Such coins could not be seen until they had gone into circulation; hence mint condition is scarce. Only very few nickels have been graded under professional services in such exemplary conditions.

Present Market Prices

• Good-4 Grade: $400-$500
• Fine-12 Grade: $800-$900
• MS-60 Grade: $2,500-$3,000
• MS-65 Grade: $45,000-$50,000

Growing Demand

The 1937-D 3-Legged Buffalo Nickel is very sought after by collectors. In recent data from the auctions, prices for this series of coins are constantly on the rise, and high-grade examples often sell much higher than their historical averages. What makes this error coin so attractive is the uniqueness combined with the history, especially regarding the very well-known Buffalo Nickel series.

3. The 1893-S Morgan Dollar

One of the highly sought-after coins in the American coin collection is the 1893-S Morgan Dollar. It is minted at only 100,000 pieces in the San Francisco Mint, which happens to be the rarest Morgan dollar in circulation.

Why is the 1893-S Morgan Dollar so Rare?

There are various reasons as to why this coin is scarce:

• Most of them were melted under the Pittman Act in 1918
• Most existing coins are worn out because they were used as a currency.
• The economic depression in 1893 saw reduced distribution

How Much is an 1893-S Morgan Dollar Worth?

Since the value of an 1893-S Morgan dollar can be very different when considering its condition, it is worth mentioning the various estimated price ranges below:

• An AU-50 About Uncirculated copy can sell for around $50,000
• MS-63 Mint State copies can fetch more than or equal to $250,000
• Well-preserved coins can command prices that fall between $100,000 and $500,000
• The highest ever recorded sale was that of an MS-65 example that sold for $735,000 in 2021

How to Identify an Authentic 1893-S Morgan Dollar

Some of the identifying features that should be on a genuine 1893-S Morgan Dollar are as follows:

• Reverse side: The clear “S” mintmark under the wreath
• Strong strike detail on Liberty’s hair on the obverse side
• Clear breast feathers on the eagle’s chest on the reverse side

4. The 1916-D Mercury Dime

The 1916-D Mercury Dime is something of a holy grail for American coin collectors, struck in Denver in the 264,000 pieces struck. Such low mintage numbers make for a hard-fought competition among serious collectors, and prices soared to dizzying heights.

In mint condition, such dimes can bring in more than $100,000. An MS-67 Full Bands example realized $207,000 in an important auction in 2019. “Full Bands” refers to the very clear horizontal bands on the fasces design-an important grading factor that can have a huge effect on value.

As a consequence of the 1916-D Mercury Dime, it was a part of a production change, creating an unintentional rarity. The Denver Mint stopped the production of the Mercury Dimes to start the production of quarters. Some essential features used when identifying this coin are listed below.

• This coin is stamped with a strong “D” mintmark on the reverse
• Well-defined wing feathers protrude from the cap on Liberty’s head
• Fasces bands are distinct in their separation
• Rim details on this coin are sharp.

Even a worn examples in Good-4 condition regularly sell for $1,000+, making this a major investment piece for serious collectors.

Tips for Finding Rare Coins

Finding rare coins takes strategic planning and dedication. Here’s how you can up your chances of finding valuable pieces:

• Search for bank rolls: Look for penny rolls from several banks. Many collectors have discovered valuable wheat pennies through roll hunting.
• Join local coin clubs: Connect with older and more experienced collectors, who share insights about rare finds and trading opportunities.
• Attend estate sales: Estate sales often produce unexpected numismatic treasures, especially from older collections.
• Metal Detector: Search through ancient buildings and historical sites (with permission) to search for buried coins.
• Meticulous Coin Counting: Most of the desirable coins are still in use. Look for:
• Penny copper coins before 1982
• Silver coins prior to 1965
• Mint marks and year combinations
• Die varieties and errors
• Responsible Coin Dealers: Maintain a good relationship with responsible coin dealers who may bring to your attention rare finds that correspond to your interest.

Never forget to research authentication methods and invest in proper coin grading guides to identify genuine rare pieces.

Understanding Coin Composition

US pennies have undergone vast compositional changes throughout their history, which directly influences their value and rarity. Pre-1982 pennies contain 95% copper, which makes them inherently more valuable than modern pennies just based on their metal content alone.

Here’s a quick breakdown of composition:

• 1909-1982: 95% copper, 5% zinc and tin
• 1982-Present: 97.5% zinc, 2.5% copper (copper-plated zinc)

You can perform a simple composition test by:

• Weighing the penny (pre-1982 pennies weigh 3.11 grams)
• Conducting a “drop test” – copper pennies produce a distinctive ringing sound
• Checking the date (1982 pennies exist in both compositions)

The 1909-S VDB Wheat Penny, being a copper-based cent, holds both numismatic and intrinsic metal value. Modern zinc-based cents lack this dual value proposition, making vintage copper pennies increasingly desirable among collectors and metal investors.

The Excitement of Coin Collecting

Coin collecting opens doors to fascinating historical discoveries and potential financial rewards. Each coin tells a unique story, from the iconic 1909-S VDB Wheat Penny to unexpected treasures hiding in your pocket change.

How to Start Your Coin Collecting Journey

Begin your numismatic journey with these easy steps:

• Join local coin collecting clubs to connect with experienced collectors
• Research authentication techniques to spot genuine rare coins
• Invest in proper storage and handling equipment
• Record your finds with detailed photographs and notes
• Set specific collecting goals, by era, mint mark, or coin type

Your next roll of pennies may hold a life-changing discovery. The hunt for rare coins such as the 1909-S VDB creates an addictive blend of history, strategy, and chance. Start your collection today-you never know which coin will become your personal numismatic legacy.

FAQs